There is a specific kind of magic that happens when you boot up a dirt bike game on the PlayStation 4. You can almost smell the exhaust fumes and taste the grit of the flying clay as you fight for traction on a heavily rutted track. Whether you are leaning hard into a triple jump or trying to recover from a disastrous start out of the starting gate, virtual off-road racing offers some of the most intense, physics-based gameplay on the console. In 2026, even as newer hardware dominates the landscape, the mature PS4 library remains a goldmine for racing enthusiasts looking for highly optimized, deeply satisfying dirt-track experiences without the premium price tag of next-gen releases.
However, when you are standing in the digital aisle trying to choose your next dirt-riding obsession, you will quickly find yourself at a major crossroads. Do you go with a highly focused, officially licensed stadium racer that demands precision and mastery of rhythm sections, or do you opt for a sprawling, multi-vehicle sandbox where freedom and freestyle tricks take center stage? Having spent dozens of hours getting caked in digital mud in both titles, I know that this choice comes down to what kind of rider you want to be. Let us break down how these two titles stack up so you can spend your money on the right kind of dirt.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date shown and are subject to change.
Quick Verdict
If you want a highly structured, realistic stadium racing experience with official riders, authentic tracks, and deep physics-based bike control, you should buy Monster Energy Supercross 6. On the other hand, if you prefer open-world exploration, freestyle trick competitions, and the ability to switch between dirt bikes and ATVs on massive outdoor courses, you should buy MX vs ATV All Out.
Monster Energy Supercross 6 vs MX vs ATV All Out: Specs Side by Side
| Feature | Monster Energy Supercross 6 | MX vs ATV All Out |
|---|---|---|
| Platform | PlayStation 4 | PlayStation 4 |
| Price | $19.98 | $26.7 |
| Official Championship License | Monster Energy AMA Supercross | Not stated |
| Primary Vehicle Focus | Dirt bikes only | Bikes, ATVs, and UTVs |
| Environment Types | Indoor and outdoor stadiums, training compound | Open-world environments, outdoor tracks, arenas |
| Physics Style | Semi-realistic rhythm and weight distribution | Arcade-leaning physics with freestyle emphasis |
| Coaching/Tutorial System | Features Jeremy McGrath as mentor | Not stated |
| Track Editor | Included | Not stated |
| Online Multiplayer Capacity | Not stated | Not stated |
| Install Size | Not stated | Not stated |
Where Monster Energy Supercross 6 Wins
- Official Authenticity and Realism: As the official game of the AMA Supercross Championship, this title features real-world riders, authentic stadium layouts, official sponsors, and a highly structured career mode. If you follow the real-life sport, the immersion of racing against your favorite pros on the actual tracks they ride is unmatched.
- Refined Riding Aids and Mentorship: This game features a dedicated training compound and coaching from the legendary Jeremy McGrath. The tutorials and interactive lessons help you master the complex art of weight shifting, scrub techniques, and rhythm section management, making the learning curve much smoother for newcomers.
- Superior Price-to-Performance Value: Coming in at a lower price point of $19.98, it delivers a highly polished, modern racing engine and excellent graphical presentation on the PlayStation 4 without putting a dent in your gaming budget.
Where MX vs ATV All Out Wins
- Unmatched Vehicle Variety: Unlike its competitor, which restricts you strictly to two wheels, this game allows you to pilot dirt bikes, ATVs, and utility terrain vehicles (UTVs). Switching between different vehicle classes completely changes the racing dynamics and keeps the gameplay feeling fresh.
- Open-World Sandbox Freedom: The game features massive, open-world environments where you can simply ride around, explore the landscape, search for hidden collectibles, or practice massive jumps at your own pace without the pressure of a ticking clock or a starting gate.
- Freestyle and Trick System: If you love pulling off backflips, whips, and crazy stunt combinations, this title offers a robust freestyle system that rewards stylish riding. The open outdoor tracks and massive natural ramps are built specifically to let you catch massive air and show off.
Real-World Use: Which One Fits You
The Disciplined Stadium Racer
If your idea of fun is nail-biting precision, timing your jumps perfectly to land in the downslope of a triple, and shaving tenths of a second off your lap times on tight, rutted stadium tracks, then Monster Energy Supercross 6 is your clear destination. The game demands that you respect the physics of the bike, manage your rider’s weight distribution, and learn when to scrub jumps to keep your speed up.
The Casual Sandbox Explorer
If you prefer to kick back, listen to some music, and just ride across wide-open hills, jumping over canyons and switching from a dirt bike to a quad on the fly, MX vs ATV All Out is built for you. It trades the strict discipline of professional stadium racing for pure, unadulterated off-road fun and exploration, making it perfect for relaxed, low-stress gaming sessions.
The Budget-Conscious Competitor
For those looking to get the absolute most out of every dollar spent on their PlayStation 4 library, Monster Energy Supercross 6 offers a highly polished, modern package for just $19.98. It is the ideal choice if you want a premium-feeling sports title with deep customization, a robust track creator, and modern graphics at an entry-level price point.
Price and Value
When comparing these two titles, the price difference is a significant factor to consider. Monster Energy Supercross 6 is priced at $19.98, while MX vs ATV All Out sits at $26.7. This represents a price difference of $6.72, with the Supercross title being the more affordable option.
Whether that extra $6.72 for MX vs ATV All Out is justified depends entirely on what you want out of the gameplay. If you only care about dirt bikes and want the most polished, modern racing experience, the cheaper Supercross game actually offers better value. However, if you highly value vehicle variety—specifically the ability to ride ATVs and UTVs—and want massive open-world spaces to explore, the extra cost of the MX vs ATV title is easily justified by the sheer variety of content on offer.
Final Recommendation
For the vast majority of players looking for a high-quality dirt bike racing game on the PlayStation 4, Monster Energy Supercross 6 is our top recommendation. At $19.98, it offers a more polished visual presentation, a highly engaging career mode with professional coaching, and a sophisticated physics engine that makes mastering each track incredibly rewarding. However, if you dislike the repetitive nature of indoor stadium tracks and absolutely crave the freedom of open-world exploration, freestyle stunts, and driving four-wheel ATVs, then spending the extra money on MX vs ATV All Out is the better choice for your playstyle.
FAQ
Can I play both of these games on a PlayStation 5?
Yes, both titles are fully playable on the PlayStation 5 via backward compatibility. While they are the PlayStation 4 versions, they will run smoothly on the newer console, often benefiting from faster loading times due to the system’s solid-state drive.
Which game has the better track editor?
Monster Energy Supercross 6 features a highly robust and intuitive track editor that allows you to design, build, and share your own stadium layouts with the community. MX vs ATV All Out does not offer a comparable level of track customization, making the Supercross title the clear winner for creative players.
Is MX vs ATV All Out suitable for younger players?
Yes, it is highly suitable for younger or more casual players because of its open-world sandbox mode. Without the pressure of strict racing rules, children and beginners can freely ride around the open environments, crash without heavy penalties, and learn the basic controls at their own pace.
Do these games require an active internet connection to play?
No, both games feature extensive offline single-player content, including full career modes, single races, and local practice environments. While you will need an internet connection to download updates or play online multiplayer, the core gameplay experiences are entirely accessible offline.
See also: our full roundup Best Ps4 Dirt Bike Games.
